ColumnKeeper: Efficient Solutions to the ColumnDisturb Vulnerability in DRAM-based Systems

Modern DRAM chips are vulnerable to read disturbance phenomena such as RowHammer and RowPress, which induce bitflips after accessing nearby rows a certain number of times (the read disturbance threshold). ColumnDisturb is a new, fundamentally different DRAM read disturbance phenomenon. Specifically, ColumnDisturb (i) disturbs DRAM columns instead of rows, and (ii) increases the number of affected DRAM cells from those in only a few neighboring rows to all cells across three consecutive DRAM subarrays. We propose ColumnKeeper, the first set of ColumnDisturb mitigations, in two variants: ColumnKeeper-D (CK-D), a deterministic mechanism, and ColumnKeeper-P (CK-P), a probabilistic one. CK-D exploits DRAM's open-bitline architecture to provide deterministic security guarantees at low performance and energy overheads: it uses two counters per subarray to track activations affecting the odd and even columns, and refreshes one row in a subarray when either counter reaches a predetermined threshold. CK-P instead refreshes one row in three consecutive subarrays upon a row activation in the middle subarray, with a predetermined probability, providing configurable security guarantees at low area overhead. Both mechanisms prevent ColumnDisturb bitflips at low performance, energy, and area overheads. At the current experimentally-demonstrated ColumnDisturb threshold (1M), CK-D and CK-P incur very low average single-core performance overheads of 0.15% and 0.36%, respectively. For near-future thresholds (128K), these rise to a still low average of 1.70% and 2.73%. Mitigating ColumnDisturb at low thresholds (e.g., 16K) remains possible by adopting smaller subarray sizes or enabling subarray-level parallelism. CK-D and CK-P require low area overheads of 0.1 mm^2 and 0.03 mm^2, respectively. ColumnKeeper is freely available at https://github.com/CMU-SAFARI/ColumnKeeper .